Squash soup, bread and coffee on a wooden cafe table beside an old white-trimmed window overlooking a late-autumn stone wall.

Where Easton Eats the Week Before Thanksgiving

November 19, 2026

Gale Papageorge grew up riding her bike down Old Redding Road with friends to have lunch at the Olde Bluebird Inn, then swimming at the Easton Pool, which is now Aspetuck Park. She told that story in a 2025 piece for The Cultural Easton. That route still works. The Bluebird is still on Route 58. Most of the places in town that feed people are just as old.

Here are the dates. The Bluebird's building went up in 1919. Silverman's Farm has been selling to the public since 1920. The Greiser family took over the store on Center Road in 1926. All three opened within seven years of each other. Gourmet United, the newest kitchen in town, opened in the former Easton Village Store.

So eating out in Easton means going back to the same few addresses, and in the last two years several of them have started cooking things they never cooked before. With Thanksgiving a week away, here is what each one has.

Route 58: the Bluebird keeps its menu close to how it was

The Olde Bluebird Inn is at 363 Black Rock Turnpike. It sits between the Bluebird gas station and Aspetuck Park, and it started out as a bed and breakfast. Inside there's an old-fashioned dining room, an enclosed porch and a lunch counter. The walls have filled up over the years with a framed map of Easton, yellowed newspaper clippings about the place, a washboard and a cast-iron spoon described as "the size of an oar."

Chester Pogorzelski runs the Bluebird with his wife, Eva. He told The Cultural Easton, "We have strived to keep the Bluebird basically the same, since that's what our customers expect and love about this place." Muffins and coffee cake are made by hand every morning in blueberry, oat bran, orange cornbread and poppy seed, and everything is cooked to order. On the regular menu you'll find blueberry pancakes with real maple syrup, a Reuben and peach blueberry cobbler. Regulars also order the chicken curry salad, the Oscar breakfast special and the homemade soup of the day.

The Bluebird serves breakfast and lunch only, and the kitchen closes at 2 p.m. Its website lists Tuesday through Sunday. During Thanksgiving week, call ahead at 203-452-0697 before planning a family breakfast there.

Center Road: Greiser's turned 100 this year and now bakes in its basement

Greiser's Coffee & Market is at 299 Center Road. The Greisers took over the lease from the Ruman Brothers in 1926 and made it a general store. That makes 2026 the store's hundredth year. The Easton Courier noted the anniversary in its preview of the town's August farm tour, when Greiser's planned to give free iced coffee to visitors carrying the tour map.

Adrienne Burke runs the store today. On the shelves are cheeses, local maple syrup and the everyday groceries people run out for, like a half gallon of milk or a six-pack. There's also a gallery of work by local artists and handmade goods for sale. Our earlier post on farm-to-table life in Easton covers the farms around town.

What's new is the baking. According to the Easton Courier, Burke said part of the basement is used to bake croissants and pastries. A store that has sold coffee and groceries for a century now bakes its own pastries.

Greiser's has published hours of 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. on weekdays and 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. on weekends. For Thanksgiving week, call ahead at 203-220-9424.

Sport Hill Road: the old Village Store now does Indian and Mexican takeout

The Easton Village Store at 440 Sport Hill Road closed in June 2022, and the building sat empty for almost three years. Inside, the kitchen was reconfigured and the old eat-in area came out.

The Easton Courier reported that the building reopened on May 6, 2025 as Gourmet United, a kitchen that serves only Mexican and Indian takeout. It's run by chef Prasad Chirnomula and his business partner, Ron Berry. Chirnomula's Indian restaurants have been around Connecticut for decades, including the Thali locations and Chef Prasad in New Canaan. CT Bites reported that Berry said permits and renovations took them more than a few years, partly because, as he put it, "It's two restaurants!"

The Mexican side has birria tacos made with slow-cooked brisket and served with consommé, mole rojo with chicken and potatoes, and a large order of nachos. The Indian menu has samosas, curries, biryani and naan. You can order at the counter, but ordering on the Gourmet United website cuts down the wait. In the days before Thanksgiving, when the kitchen at home is full of pie dough and brining turkey, it's an easy dinner.

Further up Sport Hill Road: Thanksgiving pies

Silverman's Farm is at 451 Sport Hill Road, which is Route 59, about two and a half miles north of Merritt Parkway Exit 28, formerly Exit 46. CT Bites' 2026 holiday pie guide reports that Silverman's is taking Thanksgiving pie orders in 16 flavors and will be open on Thanksgiving Day. Flavors on the farm's pie page include Pumpkin, Pecan, Dutch Apple, Caramel Apple Nut, Coconut Custard and Fruit of the Forest. The farm market is open through December 31, 2026, with produce, dairy, jams, condiments and sweets. The pie page asks customers to call the farm to order, and ordering ahead is the safest way to get the flavor you want.

Sport Hill Farm is farther up the same road at 596 Sport Hill Road. It's a small family farm that has run a curated market since 2000. This year it's also a pickup spot for Baked and Sauced, a Norwalk bakery. Pies, cakes and cinnamon rolls ordered from Baked and Sauced will be ready at the farm on Wednesday, November 25, from 10 a.m. to noon. Orders closed on November 16, so if you placed one, put the pickup window on your calendar. If you missed the deadline, Silverman's is back down the same road.

If you're out on Sport Hill Road anyway, our post on apple season along this road covers the orchards that supply these pies through the fall.

The week, stop by stop

Before Thanksgiving, the order of stops mostly follows the time of day. The Bluebird is for breakfast and has to be done by 2 p.m. Greiser's sells pastries and coffee from 7 a.m., and it's the place for the milk or butter someone forgot. Silverman's is for pie, and it's the one on this list that is confirmed open on Thanksgiving itself. Sport Hill Farm's Baked and Sauced pickup is on Wednesday morning. Gourmet United covers the nights when nobody at home wants to cook.

Three of those five kitchens were part of Easton by 1926. A fourth moved into the building that used to be the Easton Village Store. The only one not tied to an old building is a bakery's holiday pickup at a farm stand. To find more of Easton's history, start with our Easton neighborhood page.

At Jennifer Lockwood Homes, knowing Easton means knowing where the croissants are baked and which farm on Sport Hill Road takes pie orders by phone. If you're thinking about buying or selling a home near Center Road or Sport Hill Road, request a complimentary market consultation and we'll talk through how this part of town fits your plans.

work with Jennifer

With a deep understanding of the luxury market and a commitment to staying ahead of the curve when it comes to technology and communication, I am able to provide a truly unparalleled level of service to my clients.